Opinion 
 Blogs 
 National Comment 
 Let the wisdom of youth lead social agenda 

Let the wisdom of youth lead social agenda

"If you're not a liberal when you're 20, you have no heart. If you're not a conservative by the time you're 40, you have no brain.''

This silly and offensive adage, deployed to patronise the young, needs to be put to bed. Yet it lurks in the minds and actions of the powerful, and sneakily informs the public debate.

It is reflected in the rhetoric of politicians and their desperate pleas for the attention of ''working families''. So rarely is even a token gesture of political recognition extended to the young or single that we may as well not exist.

It seems increasingly that the political landscape in Australia is a battle of self-interest and greed. The cost of living has somehow become the single issue for federal government.

And the big picture is relegated to some distant rung way down the ladder. The Minister for Trade, Craig Emerson, speaking on Sky News's AM Agenda, wanted to list issues more pressing than same-sex marriage. ''Cost of living pressures, interest rates, and so on,'' were all he could muster.

Others tell us same-sex marriage is not a mainstream concern. But the evidence tells a different story. A Galaxy poll in October had support for gay marriage at 62 per cent. Among those under 34, support was 79 per cent.

So who are the people the government is frightened of? They are overwhelmingly old (46 per cent of over-50s did not want gays to marry), and frequently in marginal seats.

That's a stark figure, but the question we should be asking isn't ''Why?'' It's ''Who cares?'' Who cares if retirees, who are already married or divorced, don't like gay marriage? Who cares if pensioners are against a republic? It's not their future, and therefore it's not their place to decide.

That is not to say the elderly have no right to an opinion on gay marriage and to vote based on that opinion. But the weight and consideration given to that opinion should be less.

The failure of the two main parties to entice the young is evident on entry to any branch meeting across Australia. If branches are stacked by anyone, it is the elderly - who no doubt make important contributions, but who will not form the pool of talent necessary to make a mass political party supportable and electable.

Certainly, the archetypal student politician perseveres, hacking away as a staffer or in the back of some union office - but for other young people, with genuine dreams and ideas, there is only disillusionment.

What an improved country this would be if we formed policy with deference to the people who have something at stake. If we paid more heed to pensioners on the issue of welfare and hospitals. If we asked students for their input on education policy. If we listened to the young for guidance on big reforms.

But our political system allows for no such finesse. Rather, the most prescient opinions are always those emanating from marginal seats. It is an institutionalised travesty dictating that where you live will always matter much more than what you have at stake.

Interestingly, this does not apply to big-ticket economic reforms. Apparently when you decide to tax mining, it is the miners who are seated at the head of the negotiating table. When you implement a carbon price, the big polluters fly to Canberra for their concerns to be impressed upon ministerial ears. These policies, for some reason, do not require a consensus of public opinion. Why is 30 per cent support a good enough number to pursue a carbon tax, while 62 per cent is not enough to legislate for same-sex marriage?

Social policy seems to operate on a bizarre plane of logic where it needs almost unanimous agreement in order to move an inch. Politicians focus on the trajectory, telling us they expect change to come in the nebulous future, but we're ''not there yet''.

Well, young Australia is there on several important reforms. We've decided what we want our future to look like, and those opposed should quietly step out of the way.

Michael Koziol is studying media at the University of Sydney.

Print
Increase Text Size
Decrease Text Size
Page:
1



comments


Date: Newest first | Oldest first
Quote: "Who cares if retirees, who are already married or divorced, don't like gay marriage? Who cares if pensioners are against a republic? It's not their future, and therefore it's not their place to decide ..... But the weight and consideration given to that opinion [pensioners'] should be less." - end of quote. Michael Koziol, I am astounded that you actually submitted for readers' consideration such an ungrateful, inconsiderate and dismissive load of drivel! You say it's not our future to decide! What? Are all of us over 60 years of age about to drop off the perch? Don't you ever read about or see on TV the increasing numbers of seniors who attain the age of 90 plus or even 100 plus? Don't be too eager to write us off just yet. At the bottom of the article it states you are studying Media at university. In order that you don't become one of those who has been educated above their own intelligence I suggest that you also study (thoroughly) a course in the Humanities ....... where dismissive-minded young pipsqueaks are hopefully taught to be more respectful of their seniors.
Posted by Seven of eight, 26/04/2011 11:55:09 AM
I agree Seven of eight what ever happened to respect your elders

I find this Michael very rude and needs ro be tough some manners.

I am in 30's age range but my husband is older and I find that this Michael has made me very upset.

If it wasn't for our older range we would not have the freedom we do today so Michael go get a life and grow the f..k up.

Also remember that it is the older generation that have voted so many times to give you the right to attend University so without that generation you would not of got past year 10 under the old education system.

Posted by Happycouple, 27/04/2011 1:59:08 PM
Michael Koziol what do you want next ? Us older people to be put down by injection the day we turn 60?

The next time you attend a Lecture at your Uni make sure you have a very good look at the Lecturer as most of them would not be there as so many of them at 60 or more years of age as well.. I know because I am !!!

Posted by JamesH, 27/04/2011 2:13:04 PM
"That is not to say the elderly have no right to an opinion on gay marriage and to vote based on that opinion. But the weight and consideration given to that opinion should be less."

The most basic premise of Australian democracy is that each citiizens's vote is of equal value regardless personal characteristics. Yet you argue for less discrimination towards gays by implementing extra discrimination against older Australians. Your logic is seriously flawed.

Also flawed is your statement that only the young should have a say in the future of this country, assuming that those 50+ (old according to you) no longer have a legitimate investment in that future.

Well, pardon me while I unfog my reading glasses, but having just turned 50, I could have a good 3 to 4 decades of life left. I also have children (at Uni like you) and potential grandchildren whose futures matter very much to me. My voting considerations do not only concern myself as you wrongly assume, although I suspect yours might.

At the risk of sounding patronising, I can remember hearing undergraduate ramblings such as this in my Uni days while sipping coffee in the caf and Student Union Building.

Posted by Alicat, 27/04/2011 4:45:19 PM
michael if you are any indication of the youth of today, thank god I am not young, thank god I have had the best of Australia and I hate to think what like minded people like yourself will leave to the next generation, you sound like the new wave of progressive socialist rapidly destroying the free world
Posted by oldybutagoodie, 27/04/2011 8:43:05 PM
National Comment
Here is the place for you to vent on any national or world news and lifestyle stories on the YourGuide websites. If there is anything you see or hear that you like or don't like, tell us. Don't keep it to yourself!

Most popular articles




Harden-Murrumburrah Express







Weather brought to you by:

Weatherzone

Front Page

Current Issue
Privacy Policy | Conditions of Use | Advertising Terms | Copyright © 2012. Fairfax Media.
 SEND...
 SAVE...
 SHARE...